
Directed by Mariano Baino [Other horror films: The Trinity of Darkness (2014)]
I went into Dark Waters not knowing much at all, and while I was initially impressed, and am generally still impressed, I do wish the final product had been a bit more sensible. Certainly Dark Waters is a film that has some strong elements, but I can’t say I overall enjoyed it.
The basic story is on point – a woman goes to an island run by a religious covenant in order to speak to a friend and in the meanwhile, figure out her mysterious connection to the island. It actually reminded me of Apostle (had Apostle been made 25 years earlier) and a 1988 movie called Catacombs. Unfortunately, I didn’t enjoy Dark Waters as much as either of these films, but the potential was there.
It should be said, though, that the movie isn’t without some impressive elements, mostly being, to me, the atmosphere and occasionally quality cinematography (which I think can mostly be seen during the opening of the film, but pops up throughout). The atmosphere is due to the creepy setting (it’s not stated in the movie, but the island appears to be off the coast of Russia, as this was filmed primarily in Ukraine and Russia) and the never-ending sense of death, as these nuns don’t appear to want our main character (played by Louise Salter) to enjoy her stay.
Speaking of Salter, I can’t say that I adored her performance, but she did okay. I think the biggest issue here is that, given the story leaves out some background information (I don’t need everything tied up in a bright bow, but I do like some explanation here and there), her character isn’t easy to latch onto. It’s even harder for Venera Simmons’ character, who I suspected from the beginning of being something more. The acting is fine, but the story, while not disjointed, exactly, doesn’t always lend much focus to the performances.
Certainly the term ‘surreal’ could be used to describe some of this film, which isn’t a word I’m particularly keen on using in this case (make no mistake – this film makes 150% more sense than Eraserhead ever did), but does fit at times. I think the basics are sort of revealed, but I would have liked something more, especially given the somewhat weak and almost anticlimactic finale, which I don’t think did the previously built up tension any justice.
There was a few solid scenes, such as the death of a woman caught snooping where apparently she wasn’t supposed to, and she got #StabbedInTheBack like ten times, which was a very solid kill. Otherwise, though, there aren’t really that many kills worth noting – someone got thrown out a window, but that was more accidental than anything. As for the special effects, well, they mostly become prominent toward the finale, and since I didn’t particularly dig the finale that much, I can’t say it made too much of an impression on me.
Dark Waters isn’t a movie that I hated, but I was disappointed, especially after the eight-minute opening (all done with about no dialogue), which impressed the hell out of me. The rest of the movie didn’t really have that much to offer aside from the skeleton outline of an okay story, but I just wasn’t that enamored with where the story went, and because of that, I do feel the movie ends up below average.
5.5/10








