
Directed by Philip Kaufman [Other horror films: N/A]
Probably one of the more popular horror films I’ve not seen until now, this adaptation certainly had some strong moments, and is generally a solid movie, though I have to say I still enjoyed the 1956 version of the film more.
Based on a 1955 novel written by Jack Finney, this story follows the 1956 movie’s decently well, the most important change probably being the setting – in the 1956 movie, the setting is Santa Mira (a fictional small town); the setting in this film is San Francisco – and I do think that change is troubling.
For one, I think taking over a city of 691,000 (an estimate based on the populations of San Francisco from 1970 and 1980) would take longer than what we see in the movie. It just makes more sense to me for the action to take place in a small town (ironically, the 1993 Body Snatchers had too small a scope – a military base – so perhaps I’m just being picky).
Honestly, most of the movie is pretty good. Aside from the ending (which, because I’ve spent more than a day online, I knew was coming), though, nothing here really blew me away. Everything is pretty well done – some solid tension, some solid performances, and such – but I just didn’t walk away from this one feeling amazed.
To be fair, it’s probably very difficult for me to decouple myself from the 1956 movie, which is a film I first saw as a kid, and have seen many times since. Much like how I enjoy the 1958’s Blob movie more than I enjoy the 1988 movie, and enjoy the original Fly over the 1986 remake, based off this one viewing, I do prefer the 1956 version, and while that could change with future viewings, I’ll fully admit that I may be too entrenched in my viewpoints.
Donald Sutherland (The Puppet Masters, Alone, An American Haunting, Salem’s Lot, Don’t Look Now) was a pretty good lead. Having his character work in the Health Department was a fun choice, and I dug his personality. Honestly, neither Brooke Adams (Shock Waves, Sometimes They Come Back, The Unborn, The Dead Zone) and Veronica Cartwright (The Town That Dreaded Sundown, The Dark Below, Alien) did that much for me. I mean, they weren’t bad, but neither one interested me much.
I did love seeing a young Jeff Goldblum (Mister Frost, The Fly, Hideaway, The Legend of Sleepy Hollow, Jurassic Park) take on a solid role. He doesn’t leave as big an impression as Sutherland does, but still, seeing Goldblum is a lot of fun. Leonard Nimoy (famously Spock on Star Trek) is interesting, but I don’t know if his character adds all that much. However, in a brief scene, we do see Kevin McCarthy (star of the 1956 movie) and later Don Siegel (director of the 1956 movie), so those cameos were nice.
The special effects were quite solid, and at times, quite unnerving. Undeniably, I do think that’s an improvement over the 1956 film, and the end is certainly solid too. I do think I prefer how the 50’s movie ends than I do this one, but I can’t deny that the ending is effective. Like I said, I saw it coming, as I’ve seen the picture of Sutherland’s character pointing before, but it was still a good final sequence.
When it comes down to it, I think Invasion of the Body Snatchers was a good movie, but nothing here, save the finale, did that much for me. It’s a good story, of course – we already knew that from the 1956 movie – and the performances were overall solid, but with just a single viewing, I think I’ll stick with the 50’s movie for now.
7.5/10








